Helen Johns Kirtland — A Woman on the Front Line on the Piave

Col Maòr7 min read

Helen Johns Kirtland — A woman on the front line on the Piave

In 1918, along the muddy banks of the Piave, among ruined villages and still-smoking trenches, an American woman with a camera round her neck was calmly chatting with soldiers of the Royal Italian Army. Her name was Helen Johns Kirtland. And that image – now kept at the Library of Congress in Washington – holds her whole extraordinary story.

 

A life outside the norm

Helen Johns Kirtland was born on 28 March 1890. She was the daughter of Henry Ward Johns, founder of the Johns Manville Corporation. After her father’s death in 1898, her mother moved the family to Lawrence Park, an artists’ colony in Bronxville, New York. Helen grew up in Yonkers and in 1904 attended a girls’ school in Germany, becoming familiar with languages and with Europe.

This cosmopolitan background – several languages, knowledge of European places and cultures – made her exceptionally suited to a role no one at the time would have imagined for a woman: front-line war correspondent.

Marriage and war

Helen married Lucian Swift Kirtland on 11 November 1917 in Bronxville. The two left immediately for France because of Lucian’s work as a correspondent for Leslie’s Illustrated Weekly. Only a handful of American women obtained credentials to work as war correspondents during the First World War. Helen and her husband Lucian both obtained this permission in 1917.

But Helen did not accept a secondary role. By policy, husband and wife could not work together: they went their separate ways and met only occasionally. It was not a fallback – it was a deliberate choice.

▪ A journalist, not a journalist’s wife

Helen worked in Europe under the auspices of the YMCA, as a guest of the American army and navy, and became a correspondent for Leslie’s Illustrated Weekly. She was perfect for the role: she knew western Europe well, spoke several languages and had a natural instinct for seeing the world through a lens. She wanted to be recognised for what she was: a journalist.

In the trenches with helmet and gas mask

Perhaps the most emblematic image of Helen Kirtland shows her inside a trench during the war: she is wearing a helmet and a military greatcoat, with a gas mask hanging round her neck. It is not the pose of a war tourist. It is the portrait of someone who was really there, sharing the soldiers’ risks in order to tell their story.

As a photographer for Leslie’s Illustrated Weekly, Kirtland often travelled with the YMCA, which ran recreational and physical activities for the troops. Thanks to these contacts she could spend time with the soldiers in the trenches, learn from their experience and photograph it. Her articles for Leslie’s were simple and elegant, able to bring the battlefield into American readers’ homes.

▪ What was the YMCA — Young Men’s Christian Association
What it was A Christian association founded in London in 1844, which spread rapidly throughout the English-speaking world. Still active today in more than 120 countries.
In wartime During the First World War it ran support facilities for soldiers behind the lines: canteens, dormitories, recreation rooms, libraries, entertainment, postal and spiritual services. A kind of Red Cross of the soul, caring not only for wounded bodies but for the troops’ morale.
For Helen Working under the auspices of the YMCA gave her legitimate access to war zones, contacts with military commands and the chance to be close to the trenches. It was a valuable pass in a military world that closed almost every door to women journalists.

On the Piave: a witness to history

Helen Kirtland’s involvement on the Italian front is one of the most significant – and least known – chapters of her career. She was at the actual front during the last offensive, at the battle of Monte Grappa, and followed the army all the way to the mouth of the Piave. She was not photographing from a safe position behind the lines: she was there, in the thick of it.

One of her reports covers the fighting near the Piave, with photographs of Austrian trenches just captured by the Italians. The published images show soldiers on the march, a YMCA car among the ruins of a village near the Piave, and Helen Kirtland as Italian soldiers show her the freshly captured Austrian trenches.

▪ The handshake photograph

In the lead photograph of this article, kept at the Library of Congress, Helen is shaking hands with an Italian soldier who is holding up a copy of La Tribuna Illustrata – the popular Italian illustrated magazine, the equivalent of the American Leslie’s for which she herself worked.

It is probably no coincidence. One of the YMCA’s official tasks was precisely to bring reading material to the troops – newspapers, magazines, books – as part of supporting the soldiers’ morale. Helen travelled with the YMCA and had direct access to these distribution networks. It is therefore entirely plausible that she and her colleagues physically carried newspapers to the front line, handing them to the soldiers as a concrete gesture of closeness.

There is, however, a second reading, perhaps even more significant: war correspondents often brought copies of the papers carrying their articles to show the soldiers they had portrayed. It was a gesture of respect and of giving back – «look, I wrote about you, your story is reaching America». In this sense the handshake takes on a precise meaning: the silent pact between those who fight and those who tell the story, between those who live history and those who preserve it.

A byline erased

Helen Kirtland’s success was not without a heavy shadow: the systematic invisibility reserved for women in the journalism of the time. As a photographer for Leslie’s Illustrated Weekly and other American periodicals, she also worked for the Red Cross and obtained reporting opportunities from the United States Army and Navy.

In the 1920s the Kirtlands worked as a couple travelling the world: the Bahamas, the Philippines, France, India, Afghanistan, China, Japan, Turkey, Russia and many other countries. While Lucian wrote the articles, Helen took the photographs. But most of the time her pictures were not credited.

In her personal copy of Leslie’s Photographic Review of the Great War, she wrote in pencil «By H.K.» next to an uncredited photograph. A small, silent gesture, but full of meaning: the claim of an author who did not want to be erased from history.


Her legacy

At the end of the war, the Kirtlands worked together to document the peace negotiations at Versailles. Helen became a member of the Society of Woman Geographers, founded in 1925 for women who had done distinctive work adding to knowledge of the world. The definition fitted her perfectly.

Helen Johns Kirtland died on 3 October 1979. She had crossed the 20th century camera in hand, from the Piave trenches to the world’s capitals, leaving an extraordinary archive – largely anonymous, at least until historians began to give her back her name.

Today her photographs are kept at the Library of Congress in Washington, in the collection Helen Johns Kirtland and Lucian Swift Kirtland photographs of World War I in Europe. They are images of Italian soldiers on the Piave, of ruins and determination – but also of a woman who had decided to bear witness to history, whatever the cost.

A camera, a helmet, a war front.
Helen Johns Kirtland was there. And she has never stopped being there.

 

Cover photo: Helen Johns Kirtland with Italian soldiers on the banks of the Piave

Leave a comment

Mandaci una Email
Whatsapp